• Biblical Families is not a dating website. It is a forum to discuss issues relating to marriage and the Bible, and to offer guidance and support, not to find a wife. Click here for more information.

Indigenous wonderings

The whole site is dedicated to a theoretical discussion whose practice is also illegal.
Not theoretical. Lots of folks live plural marriage.
It’s not illegal to cohabitate with more than one person. The illegality is registering both as legal marriages. The supreme court has already ruled that cohabitation is legal.
 
Marrying at puberty is by all accounts statutory rape. Where this can be a discussion in theory, in practice it is illegal.

If we're talking about older men marrying them, and not young people marrying each other, that's disgusting. I can't imagine pretending to have a relationship with someone who's too young to understand or relate to anything I'm experiencing in life.

The whole site is dedicated to a theoretical discussion whose practice is also illegal.

I'm really curious. You seem to always be trying to bite your tongue here.
 
If we're talking about older men marrying them, and not young people marrying each other, that's disgusting. I can't imagine pretending to have a relationship with someone who's too young to understand or relate to anything I'm experiencing in life.

If you go check your own history in Ancestry you'll likely find a few marriages with young women and older men. It used to be quite common in much of the West until the 1950's to 1970's.

The whole site is dedicated to a theoretical discussion whose practice is also illegal.

Nope, not at all. It is not illegal for consenting adults to live together as a family.
 
If you go check your own history in Ancestry you'll likely find a few marriages with young women and older men. It used to be quite common in much of the West until the 1950's to 1970's.
Very, very true. It’s not uncommon. It’s in my family tree for certain.

However, I think we’re getting lost in a semantical salad.

@Maddog stated being opposed to marriage with one of the partners being AT puberty. I’m going to assume by AT he means starting, or in the process of being in puberty, which is different from having gone THROUGH puberty.

Regardless of our feelings on age gaps, or age of consent, this forum/ministry has always advocated that local laws and biblical guidelines should guide marriageability.
 
Not theoretical. Lots of folks live plural marriage.
It’s not illegal to cohabitate with more than one person. The illegality is registering both as legal marriages. The supreme court has already ruled that cohabitation is legal.
But we are not discussing cohabitation we are discussing marriage, which is Illegal.

The point I am making is, yes it is an uncomfortable subject, prehaps it stirs up in you that its inherently wrong, makes you feel protective, angry even but that's the way plural marriage makes some people feel too.

In cultures where plural marriage is accepted and practised, it is often accompanied by the marriage of very young brides. So its important to look at what the Bible says about the practice and how it weighs in on the topic.
 
But we are not discussing cohabitation we are discussing marriage, which is Illegal.

The point I am making is, yes it is an uncomfortable subject, prehaps it stirs up in you that its inherently wrong, makes you feel protective, angry even but that's the way plural marriage makes some people feel too.

In cultures where plural marriage is accepted and practised, it is often accompanied by the marriage of very young brides. So its important to look at what the Bible says about the practice and how it weighs in on the topic.
It depends on how you define marriage. A person who enters into a relationship willingly with another person and stays with that person for life or a long period of time is often civilly and legally considered “common law” spouse. No civil or legal ceremonies took place for that to be bestowed. That cohabitation is not illegal. Now, if another person is added to the household, nothing prevents them from cohabitation for a duration or life with or without a ceremony.

In regards to cultures with young brides, it’s not just in polygynous societies. Hindu culture (which isn’t antipolygyny, but it’s not the norm) is known to pledge and marry off two very young people, even if consummation doesn’t happen for many years after.

I do hope that you’re not insinuating that any of us here advocate for child brides. That’s a concept that is soundly objected to around here. Advocates are chased away.
 
So it’s important to look at what the Bible says about the practice and how it weighs in on the topic.
If you go looking for a specific age, you won’t find one. It’s impossible to pinpoint.

The scriptures indicate that one must be post pubescent. But that age differs from person to person.

Local Legalities don’t make things definitive either. Age of consent laws vary from country to country and state to state in the US. In many places it’s 16. But that would run afoul of the Bible if the person at 16 isn’t post pubescent. It’s not common but it’s not unheard of for some females to experience menses until 17 or 18. In that case, the Bible trumps civil guidelines.

Around here, we advocate that both the biblical and civil guidelines must not come into conflict. If there is, then always follow the local, civil guidelines.
 
I do hope that you’re not insinuating that any of us here advocate for child brides. That’s a concept that is soundly objected to around here. Advocates are chased away.
I am not at all insinuating that anyone here advocates for child brides! I am wanting to know how we decide how young is too young biblically.
If you go looking for a specific age, you won’t find one. It’s impossible to pinpoint.

The scriptures indicate that one must be post pubescent. But that age differs from person to person.

Local Legalities don’t make things definitive either. Age of consent laws vary from country to country and state to state in the US. In many places it’s 16. But that would run afoul of the Bible if the person at 16 isn’t post pubescent. It’s not common but it’s not unheard of for some females to experience menses until 17 or 18. In that case, the Bible trumps civil guidelines.

Around here, we advocate that both the biblical and civil guidelines must not come into conflict. If there is, then always follow the local, civil guidelines.
Do you have a reference for the scripture that says you need to be post pubescent? That would be very helpful.
 
If we're talking about older men marrying them, and not young people marrying each other, that's disgusting. I can't imagine pretending to have a relationship with someone who's too young to understand or relate to anything I'm experiencing in life.
Your thinking appears to be greatly influenced by your local culture. In the culture where I live, an older guy who keeps himself fit and well is about the hottest thing a woman wants. He is regarded as a trophy husband, prized by the young women. I learned a while ago some families consider it a rise in status for their daughter to marry such a man. Heck, I'm in my 60's and I get hit on by girls a lot younger than my daughters. But the culture here is also strongly monogamy-only, so there are challenges if a man wants more than one wife.
 
Your thinking appears to be greatly influenced by your local culture. In the culture where I live, an older guy who keeps himself fit and well is about the hottest thing a woman wants. He is regarded as a trophy husband, prized by the young women. I learned a while ago some families consider it a rise in status for their daughter to marry such a man. Heck, I'm in my 60's and I get hit on by girls a lot younger than my daughters. But the culture here is also strongly monogamy-only, so there are challenges if a man wants more than one wife.
Philippines, right?
Single American men over 45 can pretty much get the pick of the litter of the single 18-25 year old women crowd.
 
Do you have a reference for the scripture that says you need to be post pubescent? That would be very helpful.
Like the number of wives, Scripture doesn't give an age/number for marriage. Betrothal can occur at an age, but marriage and consummation is another matter. We learn from 1 Corinthians 7:9, if they cannot exercise self-control, let them marry. For it is better to marry than to burn with passion. The physical need the couple has is obviously a factor God has given for consideration. However, love for one's neighbour (cf. Matt. 22:39) must never be compromised as it is a command governing every aspect of life.

Different countries have different age of consent laws, so we abide by those laws, but governments have gone way beyond what God intended and made legal what Scripture forbids and made illegal what Scripture permits. Society is in a mess because of the interference of governments in personal matters, and it's only getting worse.
 
Yes, the Philippines but also some other Asian cultures. Particularly foreign men from many countries but also well-heeled local older men are prized. Age-gap relationships are looked up to, not looked down on, but sadly the weird and whacky western cultural influences are spreading around the region rapidly.
 
Yes, the Philippines but also some other Asian cultures. Particularly foreign men from many countries but also well-heeled local older men are prized. Age-gap relationships are looked up to, not looked down on, but sadly the weird and whacky western cultural influences are spreading around the region rapidly.
Money is an aphrodisiac in all cultures…😂
 
Yhe sge gap between my husbamd smd hos second is 22 years. That was no problem when she was 25 but he wouldn't have looked at her at even 18.
 
Back
Top