• Biblical Families is not a dating website. It is a forum to discuss issues relating to marriage and the Bible, and to offer guidance and support, not to find a wife. Click here for more information.

alternatives to oral contraception for medical issues

From a faith perspective- the Lord can open and close the womb, I don't think a pill is going to stop divine intervention.
Yes, it is God who opens and closes the womb. God has authority over life and death, so He has the freedom to create life and end life, and no one knows when that might occur. However, willfully taking a life God has not give a person the right to take is clearly contrary to His law. He makes the rules and our responsibility is to know and obey them... sort of like driving a car on a public road. There are consequences when, even with good intentions, one violates the road rules. :)
 
Yes, it is God who opens and closes the womb. God has authority over life and death, so He has the freedom to create life and end life, and no one knows when that might occur. However, willfully taking a life God has not give a person the right to take is clearly contrary to His law. He makes the rules and our responsibility is to know and obey them... sort of like driving a car on a public road. There are consequences when, even with good intentions, one violates the road rules. :)
I wouldn't really argue against that necessarily, but we all know that if the Lord wants something to happen, it'll happen.

It seems like "taking a life," only matters in specific contexts though.

Why are the large amounts of fertilized eggs lost monthly, over time when a couple has unprotected sex not considered "taking a life?" Why do those fertilized eggs seem to matter less than those of a woman who is taking birth control?

Take away the intentions and motives behind it all, and you still have the same result at the end of the day. Actually, the women taking birth control are way more likely to be the ones having far fewer "abortions" overall.

When I mentioned that maybe the women on birth control don't intend to cause abortions, I was told that intentions don't matter because the end result is the same, and that it doesn't matter if it's "fair" or not because that's just what happens.

Well, I guess the same rule should apply in all contexts? Maybe it isn't "fair" that couples having unprotected sex every month cause "abortions," but it still happens. Why aren't y'all waiting with pitchforks outside their doors monthly?

So far, nearly every response i've gotten comes across as, "intentions only matter when I say they do." Some people can participate in actions that result in "abortions" and it's fine, while others can't, and I get to decide when the loss of a fertilized eggs actually matter, based on the rules and definitions I created for the entire situation.

It seems like selective outrage to me.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't really argue against that necessarily, but we all know that if the Lord wants something to happen, it'll happen.

It seems like "taking a life," only matters in specific contexts though.

Why are the large amounts of fertilized eggs lost monthly when a couple has unprotected sex not considered "taking a life?" Why do those fertilized eggs seem to matter less than those of a woman who is taking birth control?

Take away the intentions and motives behind it all, and you still have the same result at the end of the day. Actually, the women taking birth control are way more likely to be the ones having far fewer "abortions" overall.

When I mentioned that maybe the women on birth control don't intend to cause abortions, I was told that intentions don't matter because the end result is the same, and that it doesn't matter if it's "fair" or not because that's just what happens.

Well, I guess the same rule should apply in all contexts? Maybe it isn't "fair" that couples having unprotected sex every month cause "abortions," but it still happens. Why aren't y'all waiting with pitchforks outside their doors monthly?

So far, nearly every response i've gotten comes across as, "intentions only matter when I say they do." Some people can participate in actions that result in "abortions" and it's fine, while others can't, and I get to decide when the loss of a fertilized eggs actually matter, based on the rules and definitions I created for the entire situation.

It seems like selective outrage to me.
No selected outrage from me, just the biblical reality.
 
I'm confused, maybe I'm just not understanding what you're saying. Are you referring to the Plan B type of pills specifically, or typical birth control? If you're referring to standard birth control, then how can someone abort something that never existed? No egg is released, no fertilized embryo is created in the first place. Birth control works before all of that happens.

Any method of birth control that prevents the implantation of a fertilized embryo is an abortifacient.

Any method of birth control that prevents fertilization is not.

Is that clear enough?
 
Any method of birth control that prevents the implantation of a fertilized embryo is an abortifacient.

Any method of birth control that prevents fertilization is not.

Is that clear enough?
I think so. I'm adding it to my list of things to look into later when I have the time about this topic and some of the opinions being expressed. Thank you.

Edit @MeganC One more question if you don't mind, I vaguely remember you mentioning one of the wives in your family needing or trying birth control for some reason. I think I remember you saying that she didn't take it for long because she had negative experiences with it, but what were your families feelings on that and how did they handle it?
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't really argue against that necessarily, but we all know that if the Lord wants something to happen, it'll happen.

It seems like "taking a life," only matters in specific contexts though.

Why are the large amounts of fertilized eggs lost monthly when a couple has unprotected sex not considered "taking a life?" Why do those fertilized eggs seem to matter less than those of a woman who is taking birth control?

Take away the intentions and motives behind it all, and you still have the same result at the end of the day. Actually, the women taking birth control are way more likely to be the ones having far fewer "abortions" overall.

When I mentioned that maybe the women on birth control don't intend to cause abortions, I was told that intentions don't matter because the end result is the same, and that it doesn't matter if it's "fair" or not because that's just what happens.

Well, I guess the same rule should apply in all contexts? Maybe it isn't "fair" that couples having unprotected sex every month cause "abortions," but it still happens. Why aren't y'all waiting with pitchforks outside their doors monthly?

So far, nearly every response i've gotten comes across as, "intentions only matter when I say they do." Some people can participate in actions that result in "abortions" and it's fine, while others can't, and I get to decide when the loss of a fertilized eggs actually matter, based on the rules and definitions I created for the entire situation.

It seems like selective outrage to me.
God created a natural process in a womans body to release eggs. If in that process monthly a couple have fertilized them but it doesn't result in pregnancy that is beyond their control and up to God.

When someone is taking a form of birth control that can result in a fertilized egg not having the ability to implant its morally wrong.

Saying that taking a form which can encompass the above or prevent the release of eggs is just pointing more to why the method is doubly trying to be more like God. You are preventing a natural release of an egg (which for all we know has purposes beyond our understanding as well) as well as making your body inhospitable if one is fertilized.

Thou shalt not tempt the Lord thy God.

Just because God has the ability to work around any obstacle, manmade or otherwise, does not mean we should intentially put ourselves in the position to cause him to do so or test that ability.
 
God created a natural process in a womans body to release eggs. If in that process monthly a couple have fertilized them but it doesn't result in pregnancy that is beyond their control and up to God.

When someone is taking a form of birth control that can result in a fertilized egg not having the ability to implant its morally wrong.

Saying that taking a form which can encompass the above or prevent the release of eggs is just pointing more to why the method is doubly trying to be more like God. You are preventing a natural release of an egg (which for all we know has purposes beyond our understanding as well) as well as making your body inhospitable if one is fertilized.

Thou shalt not tempt the Lord thy God.

Just because God has the ability to work around any obstacle, manmade or otherwise, does not mean we should intentially put ourselves in the position to cause him to do so or test that ability.
I think the issue I'm having is most of these are theological arguments. In my head, knowing that birth control doesn't work in the manner in which some people are often arguing it does, is making it difficult for me to wrap my mind around.

I'm pushing back but at the same time I am taking notes, I want to look more into some people's opinions here and double check the things I think I "know." It'll have to wait until after the holidays though ❤️
 
Last edited:
I think the issue I'm having is most of these are theological arguments. In my head, knowing that birth control doesn't work in the manner in which some people are often arguing it does, is making it difficult for me to wrap my mind around.
But I think you’re also misunderstanding biology. Most women only release one ovum per month. It’s impossible for there to be multiple fertilizations per month that are spontaneously aborted.
 
I think the issue I'm having is most of these are theological arguments. In my head, knowing that birth control doesn't work in the manner in which some people are often arguing it does, is making it difficult for me to wrap my mind around.

I'm pushing back but at the same time I am taking notes, I want to look more into some people's opinions here and double check the things I think I "know." It'll have to wait until after the holidays though ❤️
Fair enough.

I do believe that the effects of what birth control had on a woman's body scientifically isn't fully given when women are given the option to use it. I appreciate you are planning on looking into it.

Have a blessed holiday with your family!
 
Fair enough.

I do believe that the effects of what birth control had on a woman's body scientifically isn't fully given when women are given the option to use it. I appreciate you are planning on looking into it.

Have a blessed holiday with your family!
There isn't much wisdom in relying on scientific research except to avoid worst idea.

Basic problem is that research is relying on big groups of people. It doesn't matter that medicine has dangerous effect on 1 in 100, but what effect in will on you.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top