• Biblical Families is not a dating website. It is a forum to discuss issues relating to marriage and the Bible, and to offer guidance and support, not to find a wife. Click here for more information.

Support New to all this and afraid to speak publicly

Has anyone actually had success approaching someone who's never considered this idea before?

My wife tried to talk to a friend (an older lady) about this today and she wouldn't even consider the biblical argument at all. She just shut the conversation down, saying it's a sin. If that's the reaction we get from someone totally uninvolved, I can't imagine how F2 would react.

Nope. But my situation is highly unusual, even for BibFam standards.

Studied the topic of polygyny for 9-12 months, prayed about it for 1-3 months (specifically asking the Lord to do for me what He offered to do for King David through the Prophet Nathan), didn’t go on dating websites or anything like that and the Lord hand delivered a perfectly suitable, devoted and subservient reformed young Christian woman as an “F2” who was raised in it and attends a church that is accepting of it. She was the first woman I’d ever talked to about polygyny apart from my wife at the time.

If it sounds too good to be true it is because it is, in the sense that this process with my wife and I hasn’t been pain free: it’s definitely been a sanctification accelerator.
 
Nope. But my situation is highly unusual, even for BibFam standards.

Studied the topic of polygyny for 9-12 months, prayed about it for 1-3 months (specifically asking the Lord to do for me what He offered to do for King David through the Prophet Nathan), didn’t go on dating websites or anything like that and the Lord hand delivered a perfectly suitable, devoted and subservient reformed young Christian woman as an “F2” who was raised in it and attends a church that is accepting of it. She was the first woman I’d ever talked to about polygyny apart from my wife at the time.

If it sounds too good to be true it is because it is, in the sense that this process with my wife and I hasn’t been pain free: it’s definitely been a sanctification accelerator.

What kind of churches are accepting of this? The only ones I know of are extremely liberal.
 
What kind of churches are accepting of this? The only ones I know of are extremely liberal.
Extremely conservative reformed Protestant congregations that are pro-polygyny do exist, but they're underground. They don't advertise at all, and sadly, I can't help anyone here locate one at this point. Albeit, I doubt we have many reformed folk here.

I'm particularly burdened for the converts and polygynous homesteaders that have no place to worship, and this is a matter I have been praying about and will continue to pray about, because I think patriarchs need more options when it comes to fellowship (and accountability).
 
How have people here been treated after telling others that you're in a poly marriage? Do you lose a lot of friends over it? Do they eventually come around?

I'm not yet in a plural marriage, but I've spoken to three or four close friends about the prospect of entering into one, and in two of those conversations it was not in an abstract, hypothetical kind of way, but rather in a specific, my wife and I are talking to this young lady kind of way. It's split down the middle in terms of folks being cautiously accepting of it vs. not wanting to talk about it or discouraging it.

If it pleases our LORD to bring this all to pass and it actually pans out, my wife and I aren't sure if or how we'll tell all of our friends and church family. My wife thinks that as long as she's happy with the arrangement at that point that her actual biological family will come around. But we're mentally preparing for the possibility that we will move in order to join a conservative pro-polygyny church, possibly on the other side of the country.

As other folks on here will attest, not forsaking the assembling of saints together is extremely important to me.

I can say since it's public knowledge that Rich Tidwell (RichTidwell.com) is trying to get NFCI planted in Missouri, and while I disagree with him on deaconesses and female prophets along with a few other things like the age of accountability being 20 years of age, I commend him as a brother in the Lord and recommend folks check out his content and the intentional Christian community he's looking to build.

I've long admired Anabaptists for their intentional Christian communities and think we will need many more of them in the coming days.
 
Last edited:
My wife tried to talk to a friend (an older lady) about this today and she wouldn't even consider the biblical argument at all. She just shut the conversation down, saying it's a sin.
This is really difficult because this is not just any lady, this is someone who has known me since I was a baby and who has mentored me for decades. She is also a very strong believer, very Spirit filled, and has studied the Bible for longer than I’ve been alive. She is my prayer partner and the only person (until now) that I can share things with, no matter how personal. I don’t know what I would do if I lost her friendship and her prayer support for me and my family.
 
I can say since it's public knowledge that Rich Tidwell (RichTidwell.com) is trying to get NFCI planted in Missouri, and while I disagree with him on deaconesses and female prophets along with a few other things like the age of accountability being 20 years of age, I commend him as a brother in the Lord and recommend folks check out his content and the intentional Christian community he's looking to build.

While I'm skeptical in general about anyone claiming to be a prophet in today's day and age, I don't see any Biblical reason to say that there cannot be a modern prophet. I just see so, so many claim to be a prophet and make prophecies and then conveniently forget about it after the time has come and gone.

We also have a bunch of Christian denominations who follow specific prophets, who have failed at prophecy. Mormons and Seventh Day Adventists are on my mind when I say that.

Women can have the gift of prophecy though. There are a lot of female prophets in the Bible. They're not supposed to be leaders in the church but they can be given prophecies for everyone to hear.
 
While I'm skeptical in general about anyone claiming to be a prophet in today's day and age, I don't see any Biblical reason to say that there cannot be a modern prophet. I just see so, so many claim to be a prophet and make prophecies and then conveniently forget about it after the time has come and gone.

We also have a bunch of Christian denominations who follow specific prophets, who have failed at prophecy. Mormons and Seventh Day Adventists are on my mind when I say that.

Women can have the gift of prophecy though. There are a lot of female prophets in the Bible. They're not supposed to be leaders in the church but they can be given prophecies for everyone to hear.

Perhaps, dear Brother, perhaps. Though I find it striking that the Lord sends Agabus to Paul rather than use the four daughters of Philip with that gift under the same roof as him.

The deaconess bit is a bridge too far for me. I commend Mr. Rich Tidwell for what he is trying to do in Missouri and certainly hope his endeavors are successful to the glory of God. I’m just not sure it’s a horse I could hook my cart to at this point.

If the LORD provides the means in the future for me to play some part in establishing pro-polygyny intentional Christian communities, I will certainly be encouraged by the opportunity and pray about it.
 
Perhaps, dear Brother, perhaps. Though I find it striking that the Lord sends Agabus to Paul rather than use the four daughters of Philip with that gift under the same roof as him.

The deaconess bit is a bridge too far for me. I commend Mr. Rich Tidwell for what he is trying to do in Missouri and certainly hope his endeavors are successful to the glory of God. I’m just not sure it’s a horse I could hook my cart to at this point.

If the LORD provides the means in the future for me to play some part in establishing pro-polygyny intentional Christian communities, I will certainly be encouraged by the opportunity and pray about it.

That's an interesting point about the four daughters of Philip.

I'm open to correction here but my understanding about prophecy is that nobody interprets their own dreams and visions. They receive them, then take them to a priest or spiritual leader to be interpreted. If there's a contrary situation in the Bible, I can't think of it.

To be a fly on the wall in that house!

Because people here like preaching from virtual pulprit.

Actually trying to understand others, man, that's very very bad.

If you wonder why @FeministVampireQueen doesn't like you, well now you know.

And you try same crap to me, by qouting Scripture while having zero arguments. Done even when I qoute Scripture too.

MemeFan, I'll say this as gently as I can. You've never presented as a socially capable person. I've watched for years as you ignore conversation and dig in on topics which are crazy, and have the whole forumboard asking you to step off the ledge. A few months ago you were making a well-respected member of the board deeply upset by belittling her past as an abuse victim and drove her off the boards for quite awhile. You are the least sensitive person here, on these boards.

I understand you. I've been in the entertainment industry and up to my neck in very far-left ideology for most of my life. None of it is new, I've been soaked in it. If we lined up my best or longest-term friends from my life in one big line, the vast majority of them would be ideologically similar to you. My career path exists specifically because of your mindset. That might be why you're so rankled. I have surgically studied your worldview.

The statement I just quoted above is what people call "projection" and "strawmanning."

Everyone likes FeministVampireQueen. I don't dislike her. I don't really know her. She hasn't said she "doesn't like" me. She just expressed that me (and probably other people) likewise rankle her to some degree. She's very socially capable and fits in.

self-chosen victims never have great outcomes. I'm not going to listen to him whining about made up problems when there are actual things he can just go do to change his thinking and outlook. He has everything going for him if he wants to change his life.

This is compassionate. I will give endless amounts of my time to someone who wants to come out of a tragic back story, because other men who got it together and built huge lives and families gave me their own time.

I'm just restating this again for you. If you want to continue a personal attack on me, hit me up in my PM inbox. This thread needs to be for the new couple, it's been a great dialogue.
 
While I'm skeptical in general about anyone claiming to be a prophet in today's day and age, I don't see any Biblical reason to say that there cannot be a modern prophet.
There is a difference perhaps between having a gift of prophesy, and being a prophet.
A friend of our family had his mom tell him before she died of cancer that the first child he and his wife had would be a red headed girl. That was true and she was beautiful and favored her mom.
I was raised in the mormon church...I see after studying the Bible that we have not yet reached the end of what has been prophesied. I see no need for new prophets.

16242.jpg
16244.jpg
 
Last edited:
This is really difficult because this is not just any lady, this is someone who has known me since I was a baby and who has mentored me for decades. She is also a very strong believer, very Spirit filled, and has studied the Bible for longer than I’ve been alive. She is my prayer partner and the only person (until now) that I can share things with, no matter how personal. I don’t know what I would do if I lost her friendship and her prayer support for me and my family.
I'm so glad you have someone in your life that you were able to share with. It is soo important to get outside perspectives in any suitation, and then take it with a grain of salt. Most people that love you, want the best for you and want to protect you. People that disengage from you because of your choices are often trying to control your behaviour or trying to protect themselves from your pain cause its too painful for them to feel it.

From my own experiences of being in a relationship that people that loved me would have rathered I not be in, I found that most people just wanted the best for me and if I could assure them that its best and I've made my mind up and am certain on my course of action, then they were ok. If their habit is to take their love away to control, then they may walk away, when that doesn’t work they may walk back or not.
 
Last edited:
There is a difference perhaps between having a gift of prophesy, and being a prophet.
A friend of our family had his mom tell him before she died of cancer that the first child he and his wife had would be a red headed girl. That was true and she was beautiful and favored her mom.
I was raised in the mormon church...I see after studying the Bible that we have not yet reached the end of what has been prophesied. I see no need for new prophets.

View attachment 12602
View attachment 12603
So good! Such an important distinction! People can very well have the gift of prophecy, like any other gift, there is no need to elevate that person to a God like status. We are all Gods children and can all have a personal relationship with Him and dont need to give credence to a "Prophet" to access Him for us!
 
I'm so glad you have someone in your life that you were able to share with. It is soo important to get outside perspectives in any suitation, and then take it with a grain of salt. Most people that love you, want the best for you and want to protect you. People that disengage from you because of your choices are often trying to control your behaviour or trying to protect themselves from your pain cause its too painful for them to feel it.

From my own experiences of being in a relationship that people that loved me would have rathered I not be in, I found that most people just wanted the best for me and if I could assure them that its best and I've made my mind up and am certain on my course of action, then they were ok. If their habit is to take their love away to control, then they may walk away, when that doesn’t work they may walk back or not.
These are such excellent points ❤️

I haven't fully told my family in a serious manner about my feelings regarding plural marriage yet, though I have brought it up. When I mentioned that there are benefits to it and reasons I might choose to live it myself someday, my mother and other close family members became very worried about me.

After a few back and forth surface level discussions, I basically asked them, "when have you ever known me to be someone who does something she doesn't want to do because of the influence of others?" They all conceded that this has never been an issue for me, so I asked them to trust me in this situation as well.

People often assume that only women with weak personalities are influenced into plural marriage and need their protection. This doesn't mean they have bad intentions, and I have no doubt my family wants what is best for me. I know that is where their concerns came from.
 
Last edited:
This is really difficult because this is not just any lady, this is someone who has known me since I was a baby and who has mentored me for decades. She is also a very strong believer, very Spirit filled, and has studied the Bible for longer than I’ve been alive. She is my prayer partner and the only person (until now) that I can share things with, no matter how personal. I don’t know what I would do if I lost her friendship and her prayer support for me and my family.
I have a few thoughts. It is hard when someone is known and trusted to lose that. There is a generation that had blind faith in doctors and vaccines. A lady that tought me so very much about training horses was blind to the damage the covid shot did to her. The doctors couldn't explain why she had diarrhea for 6 months. She just joked about her life being "shitty" because the stuff was running out if her depends and down her leg!

God judged those who remained fearful of entering Caanan. Those who had seen the miracles, crossed the red sea, been fed by YHWH , had seen the water come out of the rock....and STILL had no confidence in Him.
Your mentor was raised in the apostate cult of the pope who first put a penalty of excommunication on anyone who agreed with the Bible on this. She might think about it if you showed her Proverbs 17:15 and you expressed a need to be certain and asked her to help you find the verses where YHWH God condemned it, and where He gave the penalty for it. ...because Deut. twice forbids adding or diminishing from the instructions that He gave.
All that said, I am of the opinion that many who oppose this are dealing with "God is sending them strong delusion, that they should believe a lie" because they seem to take great pleasure in the unrightousness of condemning those that He has not.

We have had people we told about polygyny years ago come back and say it is not sin but they don't believe it's God's best. ..and I say best for whom?
My husband has two sisters that really didn't speak to me after. One is married to an ordained minister that claimed he wanted to discuss it via e mail, but went 6 months to a year between messages. Another of his sisters was a jerk, but seems to have gotten over it and was nice to my sisterwife when we were last at her home.
God knows your needs. He does not need any mere mortal praying for you to keep you safe, or bless you.
The miracles and provision He graced our children with through an accident two years ago the answered prayers...were described in this verse.
16246.jpg

Just cast your cares on Him because He cares for you.
 
There is a difference perhaps between having a gift of prophesy, and being a prophet.
A friend of our family had his mom tell him before she died of cancer that the first child he and his wife had would be a red headed girl. That was true and she was beautiful and favored her mom.
I was raised in the mormon church...I see after studying the Bible that we have not yet reached the end of what has been prophesied. I see no need for new prophets.

Hey I'm confused... I just tried to quote you but remove the graphic (just for the sake of saving space). Then this text quoted above appeared in the quote box. Was that in the original message you just made because it isn't visible on my screen for some reason. I just went back and highlighted all the content on the page to see if there was some text hidden under a Bible pic graphic but none appears. Weird!

Yeah I don't know anything about a difference between a gift of prophesy and being a prophet. I did use "gift of" as a turn of phrase but just want to clarify that I don't have an opinion on any potential difference between them.

I understand the four spiritual roles as Prophet, Priest, and King. Most people don't fill any of those roles. Some rare people are selected to fill one of them. Melchizedek and David both fill two, I think there were a few other guys who had more than one role but it's very rare. The Moses, Miriam, Aaron family basically fill all three roles. Yeshua (Jesus) is the only person who has filled all three roles which is singularly unique.

I agree that prophecy is not completed, the Bible is a book of prophecies and there are still many to go. When we see the phrase "The Law and the Prophets" that's specifically referring to the Tanakh: the Torah (lit. 'Teaching' or 'Instruction'; the five books of Moses), the Nevi'im (lit. 'Prophets'), and the Ketuvim (lit. 'Writings'). It's what most people call the Old Testament.



Luke 16:

16 The law and the prophets were until John: since that time the kingdom of God is preached, and every man presseth into it.

17 And it is easier for heaven and earth to pass, than one tittle of the law to fail.

18 Whosoever putteth away his wife, and marrieth another, committeth adultery: and whosoever marrieth her that is put away from her husband committeth adultery.

Verses 17 and 18 contextualize that there is something new, but the old is not put away. On this basis I don't believe that the gift of prophecy is done. I love that anecdote about the red-headed girl.

There sure are a lot of false prophets though.
 
Last edited:
This is really difficult because this is not just any lady, this is someone who has known me since I was a baby and who has mentored me for decades. She is also a very strong believer, very Spirit filled, and has studied the Bible for longer than I’ve been alive. She is my prayer partner and the only person (until now) that I can share things with, no matter how personal. I don’t know what I would do if I lost her friendship and her prayer support for me and my family.

It may also be worth mentioning that she recently lost her husband. That may make this feel more personal to her.
 
Hey I'm confused... I just tried to quote you but remove the graphic (just for the sake of saving space). Then this text quoted above appeared in the quote box. Was that in the original message you just made because it isn't visible on my screen for some reason. I just went back and highlighted all the content on the page to see if there was some text hidden under a Bible pic graphic but none appears. Weird!

Yeah I don't know anything about a difference between a gift of prophesy and being a prophet. I did use "gift of" as a turn of phrase but just want to clarify that I don't have an opinion on any potential difference between them.

I understand the four spiritual roles as Prophet, Priest, and King. Most people don't fill any of those roles. Some rare people are selected to fill one of them. Melchizedek and David both fill two, I think there were a few other guys who had more than one role but it's very rare. The Moses, Miriam, Aaron family basically fill all three roles. Yeshua (Jesus) is the only person who has filled all three roles which is singularly unique.

I agree that prophecy is not completed, the Bible is a book of prophecies and there are still many to go. When we see the phrase "The Law and the Prophets" that's specifically referring to the Tanakh: the Torah (lit. 'Teaching' or 'Instruction'; the five books of Moses), the Nevi'im (lit. 'Prophets'), and the Ketuvim (lit. 'Writings'). It's what most people call the Old Testament.





Verses 17 and 18 contextualize that there is something new, but the old is not put away. On this basis I don't believe that the gift of prophecy is done. I love that anecdote about the red-headed girl.

There sure are a lot of false prophets though.
It’s off topic anyway. Let’s try to keep this about what’s going on in this couple’s life.
 
MemeFan, I'll say this as gently as I can. You've never presented as a socially capable person. I've watched for years as you ignore conversation and dig in on topics which are crazy, and have the whole forumboard asking you to step off the ledge. A few months ago you were making a well-respected member of the board deeply upset by belittling her past as an abuse victim and drove her off the boards for quite awhile. You are the least sensitive person here, on these boards.

Even if I made social faux pass, it doesn't mean you didn't.

And regarding that issue with @MeganC, I consider that I have better relationship with her than you think. Sometimes we fight, sometimes we like each other very much.

I told then what I consider that must be told. Truth is sometimes inconvenient.

You know, husband sometimes must truly piss off his wife. It's totally unfair, but just because Lord gives me right to additional wife doesn't mean you can have additional husband.

So making women unhappy doesn't register to me as mistake by itself.

Besides, I favour less social harmony and more exploration and truth. Both have price of spitting into eyes of village witch.

I understand you. I've been in the entertainment industry and up to my neck in very far-left ideology for most of my life. None of it is new, I've been soaked in it. If we lined up my best or longest-term friends from my life in one big line, the vast majority of them would be ideologically similar to you. My career path exists specifically because of your mindset.

My estimates says that about 10k are ideologically similar to me. If I get generous, max 1M. In whole world. I highly doubt you have met person similar to me.

That might be why you're so rankled. I have surgically studied your worldview.

If you know my worldview, you would know I'm don't have resentment.

Everyone likes FeministVampireQueen. I don't dislike her. I don't really know her. She hasn't said she "doesn't like" me. She just expressed that me (and probably other people) likewise rankle her to some degree. She's very socially capable and fits in.
Do you know that @FeministVampireQueen regular takes breaks from forum? If you all so fantastic, then why she needs breaks?
 
Back
Top