• Biblical Families is not a dating website. It is a forum to discuss issues relating to marriage and the Bible, and to offer guidance and support, not to find a wife. Click here for more information.

A Pro-Polygyny Acts 4 Community Starting In Missouri

Here is what I consider "terrible". It is chiefly the joint/common ownership of property.

As someone who got unjustly kicked out of a church for telling the honest truth about Biblical polygyny, the thought of signing over all my property to church leaders seems like a bad idea.

I am also persuaded that private party ownership of property (combined with deep Christian love and generosity) is the normal Biblical pattern, rather than some sort of "Christian communism".
That doesn't sit well with me either, I've heard of Pastor Dowell doing similar things.
 
Here is what I consider "terrible". It is chiefly the joint/common ownership of property.

As someone who got unjustly kicked out of a church for telling the honest truth about Biblical polygyny, the thought of signing over all my property to church leaders seems like a bad idea.

I am also persuaded that private party ownership of property (combined with deep Christian love and generosity) is the normal Biblical pattern, rather than some sort of "Christian communism".

I don't disagree with your thinking on some of this. NFCI is going to have a two year period of examination, and thankfully don't require that everyone contribute all of their property and/or portfolio to the community, which I think is a great middle ground compared to groups like the Bruderhof that insist on you emptying out your pockets, holding nothing back and signing away any rights to any future inheritance as well.

NFCI (which, to be super clear, I am not in any way affiliated with or supportive of in any official capacity) is looking for $25K and/or a year of service spread out over time only in order to become a voting member. I think their current framework is going to run into a host of issues, but people have got to start somewhere.

If I were ever able to start an intentional Christian community, I would be looking to do something akin to an HOA, with a shared community area and private property surrounding it. However, in order navigate the complexities around equal housing, what do you do about actual apostates, etc., there would need to be a healthy amount of fine print (hopefully in plain English) such that the community could buy folks out, both in order to preserve the community and perhaps more importantly in order to not send folks away empty-handed who figure out that this isn't for them.
 
Torah-observant tend not to be bigoted in general since it requires the Biblical view that everyone is adopted and joined-in from different ethnicities and nations. That said, although I can't recall specific people I feel as though I've seen some outliers who don't fit that general description.
I know of a man who was refused fellowship to the Torah observant fellowship he started because of his second wife. The irony is thick here since there is nothing in the Torah that identifies it as sin ir prescribes excommunication for it....but there ARE verses in the Torah that prohibit adding to it or diminishing from it.

Most religious groups are every bit as prone to corruption and abuse of power as others. Happy_hen here shared how their 7th day worshipping Torah group treated them for considering polygyny in the case of a widow with 8 children as I recall. It was shameful! In my observation that is what you get when a man submits to the alleged authority of other men. It's kind of like the difference between a corrupt cop and a corrupt priest being
1. The uniform.
2. Cops don't start cults. and
3. People accept that cops can be corrupt.
In both examples the real authority is THE LAW and the one ministering it can have authority only if they remain within what THE LAW has authorized. Outside the 'scope of their authority' they are just criminals in disguise.
 
Last edited:
I have such mixed feelings on joint ownership of property. On the one hand, I'm so anti-communist. The Bible expressly supports private ownership. The Ten Commandments require private ownership. We also can get into spiritual and emotional subtopics.

Then I go look at little communes like the Hutterites. I've been a visitor to one of their communities. They have epic machinery, they pool everything and they're all very comfortable and happy due to that.

Communism always fails and brings misery when a nation tries it. But as a clear distinction I don't see an issue with small groups of people coming together and pooling their money for communal living. It's smart. It works great when everyone is actively involved and there are not any deadbeats sponging off the people working. These kinds of groups rarely work out well in the long term though because some people always start getting lazy and other people take up their slack. They need to be able to kick out the ones who don't work out. Then if Bob is giving 60% and Larry is giving 40% and they do this for twenty years, you're going to have a lot of problems with resentments, asset allocation, the reward system gets all messed up.

When we look at the ancient Israelites we can see that it's a market economy and different people do different things. If a guy wants to only work 20 hours a week, who cares. Let him do that.

The other thing we see when we look at the ancient Israelites is a master / servant system. If Tony is a bad farmer or a gambler or he drinks too much, he might lose all his wealth and go into debt. So he had to go over to Andy and be Andy's servant for seven years. During this time, Andy can help Tony straighten out his life, teach Tony him better skills, and prepare him to start over anew with a clean slate. Then, thirty years down the road, Don makes some bad decisions with women and gambles too much then he has to go work for Tony, and it's Tony's turn to be the master now.

That's a cycle of learning, teaching, growing and repenting which makes a strong community of upwardly mobile heads of households who can keep each other fruitful and creates long-term fiscal strengthening.
 
I know of a man who was refused fellowship to the Torah observant fellowship he started because of his second wife. The irony is thick here since there is nothingbin the Torah that identifies it as sin ir prescribes excommunication for it....but there ARE verses in the Torah that prohibit adding to it or diminishing from it.

Yeah I mean I'm Torah-observant but nearly our whole TO community threw us out and started spreading rumors about me which were not based on reality. All these men telling me they want me to stay away from their children and three men (and two women) who had openly discussed polygyny as lawful and acceptable to God suddenly declared it a sin (including one lady who had been in an FLDS marriage at one time).

It was an overt conspiracy because one old lady went crazy on pain meds and spun up a moral panic, and got all the wives into a wild campaign. And then the men just crumbled. I didn't even approach any of the women or anything, it was literally just a thought crime.

As a result of this, we have had small numbers of other regional people who heard the gossip about all that come forward and tell us that they support us and they are interested in learning more about it. I do think the culture is changing in little ways. We also got to see the masks ripped off a few of the women who were straight-up demonic during all that, acting like they were possessed. Our discernment is growing in leaps and bounds. And two different pastors who I know not to follow - one because he argued the legality of polygyny for four whole years then denied it and called it a sin as soon as it became socially uncomfortable, and the other because he said he didn't understand it, hadn't studied it, doesn't know anything about it, and just called it a sin because of "two sisters in her lifetime to spite her." Both of them are terrified of their (admittedly aggressive) wives.

I was raised nondenominational Protestant. I can understand how a mainstream Christian might think that polygyny is sinful. But I don't understand how anyone who has been in TO circles for more than a reasonable amount of time could make that claim. Most of the time they default to "not for this time" or "acceptable but not good."
 
Is it like this one?


This article says this compound / paradise has been around for over 40 years (adjusted for years since the article was published) and that it has at least four different denominations with over 400 people there.

Strange that we've never heard of it before. They must not have a lot of drama.

There are lots of groups out there that either avoid drama or else just practice discretion and no one notices them. I've heard from quite a few over the years. The majority seem to be small groups of two to maybe five families.

400 people is pretty impressive.
 
Is it like this one?


This article says this compound / paradise has been around for over 40 years (adjusted for years since the article was published) and that it has at least four different denominations with over 400 people there.

Strange that we've never heard of it before. They must not have a lot of drama.

More on these sort-of LDS folks:


Their ranch is centered on a business called "Bountiful Enterprises" - easy to find on Google Maps between Stockton and Humansville, Missouri.
 
Last edited:
In a group that mandates "dues", how are the dues spent? If it is to pay personnel then that group is waaaaay too large to be of use to the body as a whole. $2K a month is a mortgage payment! Rather, pooled together to purchase communal equipment is one way to use capital. The combined capital of 5 or more families could develop a great homestead. I bristle at capital being consumed by the "leader" of the group. EVERYBODY works for gain- no lazybutts.
 
I have such mixed feelings on joint ownership of property. On the one hand, I'm so anti-communist. The Bible expressly supports private ownership. The Ten Commandments require private ownership. We also can get into spiritual and emotional subtopics.
You don't have to have issues.

If single person owns land, by natural law, then it's monarchy. In fact, kings were often biggest landowners in kingdom.

If group together owns land, then it's republic.

Based on fact that owners have right to regulate usage of their own property. Author is read Karl Ludwig von Haller.

So real issues here:
1) What is entry fee?
2) What is "exit tax" if you decide to leave?
3) What is your expected contribution? Money, work, culture, religion
4) What are your "voting rights"?
5) How are decisions being made?
6) What are all incentives?

There is big difference between following:

A) All your property becomes investment in our business. You are regular employee. If you leave,you leave empty-handed.Payment combination of needed for live plus incentive bonuses

B) You have your own income sources. Contribution expected for communal buildings (church) and roads. Same for unemployment/healthcare fond. G
Democratic decisions for communal stuff.

A is wage slavery as you Americans like to say.

* In such community, it's unlikely fake illness and avoiding job search will stay hidden.
 
Is it like this one?


This article says this compound / paradise has been around for over 40 years (adjusted for years since the article was published) and that it has at least four different denominations with over 400 people there.

Strange that we've never heard of it before. They must not have a lot of drama.
No, this one is different from Rich Tidwell . Tidwell is in the Kansas City area, this other one is by Stockton Lake, we personally know one of the members there. They are "Torah observant" but not all, and they cling to the Lunar Sabbath, but not all. Some worship on the pagan unholy first day. Tidwell, does believe, and there are videos out there coming from his own mouth, that if you are married to anyone under the age of 20, you are a pedophile, even though in our country, 18 and above is an adult.
 
No, this one is different from Rich Tidwell . Tidwell is in the Kansas City area, this other one is by Stockton Lake, we personally know one of the members there. They are "Torah observant" but not all, and they cling to the Lunar Sabbath, but not all. Some worship on the pagan unholy first day. Tidwell, does believe, and there are videos out there coming from his own mouth, that if you are married to anyone under the age of 20, you are a pedophile, even though in our country, 18 and above is an adult.

Yes, I found his teachings on the age of accountability being 20 to be interesting but ultimately without adequate Scriptural warrant.

Sometimes I see well meaning people go beyond what is written. May the LORD forgive me of being one of these people myself, for as surely as I can spot specks in my Brother’s eye there are planks in mine. While I don’t think this realization eliminates the necessity of reproof, I do think it promotes humility and demands circumspection also.
 
Yes, I found his teachings on the age of accountability being 20 to be interesting but ultimately without adequate Scriptural warrant.
I agree with you. I looked into his claims thoroughly because I so badly wanted them to be legitimately backed by scripture, but I don't believe that's the case.

He has enough evidence to show that his opinion is a "good idea," but it's fairly obvious his teaching regarding this subject falls short of being solidly backed by scripture.
 
Last edited:
I remember someone here saying that fruit from a tree should not be harvested until 4 years. Am i misremembering here?
 
if you are married to anyone under the age of 20, you are a pedophile, even though in our country, 18 and above is an adult.
Grief! He should get his mind out of his pants. It is written, but if they cannot exercise self-control, let them marry. For it is better to marry than to burn with passion (1 Cor. 7:13).
 
I'm fairly sure I remember reading that he started a foundation to keep young girls, and boys, out of homelessness and sex trafficking. I imagine he and his wives see a lot of abuse, and I assume this could be one of the reasons for his views on this subject.
All well and good. However, labeling a person a pedophile for obeying the Word of God goes way beyond good reason. Shalom
 
I'm fairly sure I remember reading that he started a foundation to keep young girls, and boys, out of homelessness and sex trafficking. I imagine he and his wives see a lot of abuse, and I assume this could be one of the reasons for his views on this subject.
It' not that. Somebody posted here that relevant ages. 20 years is needed to be adult, therefore 20 years is needed for marriage.

He is consistent with his internal logic.
 
Back
Top