I would like to add that I see the Talmud, as great source for getting a look at ancient Hebrew cultural beliefs and Etymology of the Hebrew language. There is a lot of wisdom there but also there are
some wrong teachings. I see no difference in the opinions an interpetations of the Old Sages of the Talmud and the opinions and interpretations of the Old Sages of this Forum.
There are Greater arguments, lesser arguements, wisdom and misinterptations we try to work through.
So first I want to say, "great stuff" on some of the wisdom of the sages of old you found.
Now regarding your last post:
There is an absolute sea of difference between us meager forum commentors and the wisdom of the great sages who are quoted in the talmud.
This is not a bash on the older gents here; it's just not a fair comparison to compare working men to guys whose vocation was to study 10+ hours / day and to serve as judges in application of the bible regarding great legal cases. The difference in opinions between the folks here and the folks in those tomes is a gulf apart.
Regarding there being "
some wrong teachings" in the talmud, this is why the minority opinion is always included. The talmudic thought process is to share the majority opinion as well as the dissenting or "
wrong teaching" opinion. Talmud study is supposed to sharpen one's reasoning ability and train them in how to properly interpret Torah teaching.
As such, the compilers considered even the wrong teachings, since they were from such amazing men who had vast swaths of scripture memorized in the Hebrew, to still have some merit to it.
One great example of this is the opinion that anyone who says G-d's name out loud as it is written in the bible has no part in the world to come.
This is of course an extreme and minority opinion but the opinion itself has an ominous warning which makes us think; or at least it should, before the sacred 4 letter name of G-d is uttered, written, etc. It is the "
wrong teaching" which can at times speak volumes because of the holiness of the teacher.
I suspect your statement was made because you may be concerned about the crunching of eggshells whenever the Rabbis are referenced