• Biblical Families is not a dating website. It is a forum to discuss issues relating to marriage and the Bible, and to offer guidance and support, not to find a wife. Click here for more information.

What is the biblical basis for contraception?

This is a complicated issue, especially when we deal specifically with scripture.

The most strict hermeneutic for the command of multiplication was given to a specific couple, not humanity. If we get too far into the “ideal” narrative, then we can begin to degrade our own argument in the counter to monogamy being the edenic “ideal”. Be careful.

However, God designed all of creation with the ability to multiply, sexually or asexually. It’s part of His masterpiece. Procreation is godliness, but so is non procreation if done in deliberate or circumstantial singleness by devotion to the Lord.

Scripture doesn’t give a specific number but it does seem to implicate that more children is better than none, without giving specific numbers.

Assuming he has the ability and desire to nurture, I would say that each patriarch needs to prayerfully consider his ability to provide, and the health of his woman in determining the amount.

I don’t think natural prevention or “spilling seed” is a sin. Again, if it’s a strict hermeneutic, it was in reference to one specific person and it’s prohibition doesn’t seem to be found in any of the laws given to Moses (someone correct me if I’m wrong).

Hormonal or insertive methods that allow fertilization but prevent implantation are not biblical. They are taking the life of a full human, made in God’s image. That is sin.

Personally, as I told my wife today: I have no qualms with monogamy being labeled the Edenic ideal. I think some people may still be called to chastity and polygyny as well. Everyone else’s mileage may vary. 🤷‍♂️
 
Personally, as I told my wife today: I have no qualms with monogamy being labeled the Edenic ideal. I think some people may still be called to chastity and polygyny as well. Everyone else’s mileage may vary. 🤷‍♂️
But it’s used to indicate what the acceptable limits are. It’s a dishonest requirement, especially in light of what many accept as monogamy (divorce).
 
If one knowingly ingests hormones or places a device that prevents implantation for the specific purpose to prevent a fertilized ovum…FROM IMPLANTING
it’s the taking of an innocent life.
I noticed a very important error in my original post.

I don’t believe prevention of gamete cells from fusing is necessarily sin. Once they are fused, they become a unique life worthy of protection.
 
Those are naturally occurring at the hand of a sovereign God.

Death is in the hand of God, not man. The exception is capital punishment for the guilty who have taken the life the innocent.

If one knowingly ingests hormones or places a device that prevents implantation for the specific purpose to prevent a fertilized ovum, it’s the taking of an innocent life.

That’s why I’m for capital punishment, not abortion. One kills the guilty for killing the innocent. The other kills the innocent to protect the guilty.
Thank you for explaining that more. It's something i'm going to do more research on and put more thought into. I may have been quick to respond initially because it's very hurtful to see people say that women who are having sex and taking hormonal birth control equates to killing babies.

I'm genuinely trying to understand this perspective.

From what I've gathered, and correct me if I'm wrong but y'alls stance is more about the human intention and the actions they took that could possibly result in the fertilized eggs not taking?

And, if I follow that logic, then what happens when a woman has no ill intention behind using those medications? I guess one could argue that it doesn't matter because the results are still the same, but what if she has exhausted all other alternatives and genuinely needs hormonal birth control for medical conditions? If her intentions aren't to cause an abortion, then how is that different from a woman having unprotected sex with no intention to lose fertilized eggs, nevertheless those are the unintended results either way.

Basically if we remove the intentions, the results are the same, but somehow the punishments are different?

To answer your question on the other thread, no at this moment, this doesn't personally involve me or my lifestyle choices, I've only taken birth control for maybe a year or so total in my entire life (for medical purposes), but I know married women who are in this situation and struggling with it.

I feel like accusations as strong as these should have some serious biblical and moral foundation and backing. It hurts my heart that to think that the women i've watched struggle and shared stories with reading things like this and adding yet another burden to their already difficult situations, but if I am wrong in my opinions, then that's something very important I need to consider and put some serious thought into as well.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for explaining that more. It's something i'm going to do more research on and put more thought into. I may have been quick to respond initially because it's very hurtful to see people say that women who are having sex and taking hormonal birth control equates to killing babies.

I'm genuinely trying to understand this perspective.

From what I've gathered, and correct me if I'm wrong but y'alls stance is more about the human intention and the actions they took that could possibly result in the fertilized eggs not taking?

And, if I follow that logic, then what happens when a woman has no ill intention behind using those medications? I guess one could argue that it doesn't matter because the results are still the same, but what if she has exhausted all other alternatives and genuinely needs hormonal birth control for medical conditions? If her intentions aren't to cause an abortion, then how is that different from a woman having unprotected sex with no intention to lose fertilized eggs, nevertheless those are the unintended results either way.

Basically if we remove the intentions, the results are the same, but somehow the punishments are different?

To answer your question on the other thread, no at this moment, this doesn't personally involve me or my lifestyle choices, I've only taken birth control for maybe a year or so total in my entire life (for medical purposes), but I know married women who are in this situation and struggling with it. I feel like accusations as strong as these should have some serious biblical and moral foundation and backing. It hurts my heart that to think that the women i've watched struggle and shared stories with reading things like this and adding yet another burden to their already difficult situations.
Sister, I understand your concern, especially when judgments are rendered under sweeping generalities.

My wife has experienced female issues over the years and it’s been frustrating. That issue exists in many women whether we know the root causes or not.

My wife has never used the bc pill (s) so it’s not been a personal issue for us. It wasn’t until I began researching abortion more about 20 years ago did I realize that prevention of implantation was what was happening with most medical birth control. I always assumed it was just prevention of ovulation of some kind.

I’m not a doctor so take my two pennies for what they’re worth. If a woman’s seemingly only alternative is to use hormonal therapy for female issues, then she must be made aware of what those pills could possibly be doing to unborn life. At that point, I’d suggest looking into herbal and homeopathic alternatives as well as both medical and lifestyle alternatives.

Can her fallopian tubes be safely obstructed for a time with reversal a possibility? I’m not sure that’s possible (Im not a doctor)

Can she and her husband use prophylactics? They’re not 100% effective, but they’re reducing intent.

Is it possible to abstain for a season? It’s not pleasant, but it reduces potentially murderous outcomes.

It’s interesting that you bring this up because it seems like it’s another reason for some to consider polygyny. A woman’s value is more than sexual but if she could be relieved of knowing that she’s a man’s only alternative during a medical ordeal, it could relieve some of her anxiety or pressures. It’s another angle to consider.
 
I'm at an age where I see the pill as a form of murder. If the egg is fertilized and can't embed to live and grow, then a child is being killed.

It's much cleaner than abortion, and abortion is much cleaning than sacrificing a toddler to the flames for Molech, but the result is the same.

Over my life I have expected many women to be on birth control. Whether I made her do it or not, I feel my agreement with it at the time makes me complicit. My wife had two miscarriages really quickly back to back after coming off the pill.

Getting to the question of "If God is sovereign, and we've been commanded to be fruitful and multiply, and He opens and closes the womb, and children are a gift, are we not engaging in sinful unbelief and an unrestrained pursuit of unfruitful pleasure by preventing pregnancies?"

Yes I agree. I think you summarized my feelings well and I can't offer anything more. Sex includes reproduction. If we are using even a condom and there is no pregnancy being stopped at all, then we are acting against Yahweh's design for us. It's rebellion.
We also came to that conclusion and God blessed us with our 3 beautiful boys, not just our sweet girls. So, doing His will came with His blessings.
 
I truly believe we are still to be fruitful and multiply and fill the earth.
God told Adam and Eve to “Be fruitful and multiply; fill the earth and subdue it; have dominion over the fish of the sea, over the birds of the air, and over every living thing that moves on the earth” (Genesis 1:28). To fill the earth is a multi generational responsibility, not just one couple's duty. After the destruction of all other human life in the Flood, God told Noah and his sons to “Be fruitful and multiply and fill the earth" (Genesis 9:1). Again, a multi generational task.

When the people wanted to build a tower at Babel, it was to be a place of pagan worship and to keep them from being scattered abroad over the face of the whole earth (Genesis 11:4). God confused their language and forced them to do what He commanded - to fill the earth.

Scripture is replete with examples of godly women grieving the inability to have children, but also of God intervening and blessing some of them with offspring. He supplies to fulfil the duty He's given. And He has supplied husbands for every woman who wants one, if those women would look at His provision in polygyny. Shalom
 
If be fruitful and multiply is a universal command that applies to everyone, at what point does someone cross the line into being sinful and rebellious? Is it because they choose to not have children immediately when they can? At the moment they reach puberty? Paul tells widows that they are free to remain single, what if they never had children? Is she living in sinful rebellion? Was the apostle Paul? Were the people he wishes would remain single like him? I'm always so confused by people who insist on this because having such an opinion requires you personally deciding when other people are living in rebellion or being sinful, and at what point in their lives this begins and ends.
There are many ways to be fruitful and to multiply. Childbearing isn’t the only way, but it’s certainly the most fun. And rewarding. It’s rewarding too….

And also easiest. Having lots of kids is just easier than evangelizing people. I say have the kids.
 
Can you help me understand this better? Because normally if a woman is having unprotected sex, it's highly likely that some of her regular periods already contain fertilized eggs that failed to implant anyway.
I consider it morally wrong to stop success of fertilized egg on purpose.

Sometimes it fails naturally. Mother's body can subsonsciously decide egg is "defective" and kill it. Nothing we can do here, so it out of moral consideration.

Only action done by purpose with mind making decisions can be considered moral.
 
I just find it completely insane that our society only tolerates a man marrying a second woman if he abandons the first.
Lol,

You should study some antropology.

There was tribe that believe to insure impregnation best method is having sex with dozen men one after one. It didn't work because so much sex cause female infertility.

Or another tribe that believed that men eating "men's milk" is mandatory for men's fertility.

Or Indians with sati customer. Man dies, time to burn his widow.

Every society is slighty crazy in something.
 
I consider it morally wrong to stop success of fertilized egg on purpose.

Sometimes it fails naturally. Mother's body can subsonsciously decide egg is "defective" and kill it. Nothing we can do here, so it out of moral consideration.

Only action done by purpose with mind making decisions can be considered moral.
That's valid, but how many things do people do "naturally" even without taking birth control that can have the same results? If that's the standard then couldn't anyone not living an entirely perfect life mistakenly cause/have an "abortion?"
 
Last edited:
That's valid, but how many things do people do "naturally" even without taking birth control that can have the same results? If that's the standard then couldn't anyone not living an entirely perfect life mistakenly cause/have an "abortion?"

Big sigh. 😮‍💨

All I can say here that may help you is the same thing I say to my wife, whom I love dearly:

You can not attack a position you’re defending.

If you really want to learn spiritual truths and grow in grace, you need to be humble and be willing to be surprised.

“Trust in the Lord with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding. In all thy ways acknowledge him, and he shall direct thy paths.“ - Proverbs 3:5-6 (KJV)

Everyone is brainwashed. The only question is what you’re using to wash it. Will it be the water of the Word or the main stream of the world?

My prayer is that you would be transformed as a new creature in Christ by the renewing of your mind, that you would be given the mind of Christ and that you would allow yourself to be instructed by His Spirit in accordance with His Word.
 
Big sigh. 😮‍💨

All I can say here that may help you is the same thing I say to my wife, whom I love dearly:

You can not attack a position you’re defending.

If you really want to learn spiritual truths and grow in grace, you need to be humble and be willing to be surprised.

“Trust in the Lord with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding. In all thy ways acknowledge him, and he shall direct thy paths.“ - Proverbs 3:5-6 (KJV)

Everyone is brainwashed. The only question is what you’re using to wash it. Will it be the water of the Word or the main stream of the world?

My prayer is that you would be transformed as a new creature in Christ by the renewing of your mind, that you would be given the mind of Christ and that you would allow yourself to be instructed by His Spirit in accordance with His Word.
Actually, I value @MemeFan opinions, my question was an attempt to understand his perspective more. I'm not sure why you saw that as arrogant?
 
That's valid, but how many things do people do "naturally" even without taking birth control that can have the same results? If that's the standard then couldn't anyone not living an entirely perfect life mistakenly cause/have an "abortion?"
I think that only results determine morality of actions. Horewer, intention and knowledge do determine severity.

Like you can kill a man throught ignorance.

You can turn off power and after 15 minutes say colleague it's safe to work. Meanwhile, someone turn ons power and colleaque dies.

You did give false instruction which resulted in his death. Put you didn't know power was on again. So far less severity in moral sense. You could check power again just do be safe.

Taking aborifienct on accident or ignorance is less worse than on purpose.

Sometimes accidents where somebody dies, sadly, happen.
 
I think that only results determine morality of actions. Horewer, intention and knowledge do determine severity.

Like you can kill a man throught ignorance.

You can turn off power and after 15 minutes say colleague it's safe to work. Meanwhile, someone turn ons power and colleaque dies.

You did give false instruction which resulted in his death. Put you didn't know power was on again. So far less severity in moral sense. You could check power again just do be safe.

Taking aborifienct on accident or ignorance is less worse than on purpose.

Sometimes accidents where somebody dies, sadly, happen.
Thank you ❤️ I'm going to think more on all of this after the holidays.
 
Actually, I value @MemeFan opinions, my question was an attempt to understand his perspective more. I'm not sure why you saw that as arrogant?

Gotcha. MemeFan isn’t someone whose content I’ve seen in a while, as I prefer to associate with biblical, orthodox Christians whenever possible. If folks don’t love the Lord or wish to learn about Him in humility, I really don’t bother unless I’m preaching in the open air to the goats and the sheep.

Have a lovely holiday and I hope that you find everything you’re looking for in the Lord Jesus Christ!
 
Thank you ❤️ I'm going to think more on all of this after the holidays.
Try to think as judge. What would be sentence in which people get what they deserve?

Woman claiming 24 abortions because she is to lazy to use condoms or pill is easy case. Straight to jail.

Then you can have historical doctors who killed people because they didn't wash hand. Seems to much to execute people or send to jail who don't even know they are doing wrong. I think best case is education and doctors better to start washing hands or else...

Then you have case from my city. City as government unit has stopped paying women from have biggish families. Some women who would before receive city money have now done abortions.

This isn't easy case because financial fear is real and jail/execution doesn't fix anything by itself. Such threat will result in black market where women would be in even bigger danger. So some education how to fast increase income, better time management with threat of real punishment if case of repeat offense, would be my approach.

There is reason I'm not fan of rule of law precisely because here we have three very different situations which can't treated as same. There is no point in law which makes situation worse.

And law dealing with all possible situations would be so big and complex it would sink under it's own weight.
 
Back
Top