• Biblical Families is not a dating website. It is a forum to discuss issues relating to marriage and the Bible, and to offer guidance and support, not to find a wife. Click here for more information.

A Pro-Polygyny Acts 4 Community Starting In Missouri

Nonsense. Had she not been of the typical Hebrew age for marriage and betrothal then someone would have made a big deal of it.

"Like what the hell is wrong with Mary? She's sixteen and she isn't married?"

Likewise, being single at 28 in a time when the life expectancy was 25 to 35 would mean she was likely to die alone.

Seriously, I never understand the arrogance of imposing latter day views and values on the past. Regardless of your feelings, regardless of what the communist feminists prefer, the fact of life in the time of Jesus' birth was that Hebrew girls were married at 13 and this was perfectly normal for the time.

Insisting that Mary was different when there is utterly nothing to back up that assertion is ahistorical and it is also needlessly revisionist.

Not even the Catholics, who worship Mary, say different.

🤣 I did not say that your deductions were not good, bad or indifferent or that I even Disagree. I simply disagree that you can blantly just say that she was 13 as if it is established fact when it simply wasnt.

I can say she was probably around that age but I cant declare that she was definitely.

Umm maybe you have some strong feelings and thoughts too that drive you to present as fact something we will never actually know.
 
Solely in the interest of exhibiting charity towards Mr. Tidwell, here is his complete and unaltered justification of his understanding of the Age of Accountability.

Article 5 - Age of Accountability​


Scripture confirms that maturity and full moral accountability before God begins at twenty years of age. Leviticus 27:3-7 establishes the age brackets witnessed consistently throughout the Bible:

  • under one month is infancy,
  • one month to five years is early childhood,
  • five to twenty years is adolescence,
  • twenty to sixty years is adulthood,
  • sixty years and above is eldership.
This is confirmed by the Wilderness Narrative, in which those “from twenty years old and upward” perished for their sin (Num 14:29), while the “little ones” who had “no knowledge of good or evil” were spared and granted the Promised Land (Deut 1:39). The New Testament affirms the Levitical taxonomy as Paul requires widows receiving church welfare be “not less than sixty years old” (1 Tim 5:9), while those under sixty are directed to marry and bear children (1 Tim 5:14).

We therefore believe that children under the age of twenty are graciously granted eternal life should they die before reaching adulthood (2 Sam 12:22-23; Isa 7:15-16; Deut 1:39; Matt 19:14). Nevertheless, upon reaching twenty years of age a person becomes subject to eternal judgment and must therefore make a personal profession of faith in Jesus Christ and be baptized by immersion.

Copy & Paste into Bible Gateway: Lev 27:3-7; Num 14:29; Deut 1:39; 1 Tim 5:9; 1 Tim 5:14; 2 Sam 12:22-23; Isa 7:15-16; Matt 19:14

Extra Credit: Read “The Age of Legal Maturity in Biblical Law” by Fleishman, Joseph. 1992.
Yes, he does make a great attempt to be true to scripture. Laudable. If he’s consistent and insists his community abide by this, good on them.

I just think it diverts too far into the realm of application based on conclusions that aren’t mandated, rather than strict interpretation.

Much like Proverbs gives wisdom about alcohol usage, it’s a stretch to say it’s mandating prohibition to marry or reproduce or be accountable until 20. Good guideline but not mandatory.
 
Yes, he does make a great attempt to be true to scripture. Laudable. If he’s consistent and insists his community abide by this, good on them.

I just think it diverts too far into the realm of application based on conclusions that aren’t mandated, rather than strict interpretation.

Much like Proverbs gives wisdom about alcohol usage, it’s a stretch to say it’s mandating prohibition to marry or reproduce or be accountable until 20. Good guideline but not mandatory.

I agree 100%. I think every Christian could use a healthy dose of concern when it comes to adding to or removing from God's Word. There's three warnings like that in the Holy Scriptures: two bookend warnings and one smack dab in the middle. But nobody, and I mean nobody, has ever been able to tell me when those barking dogs actually bite.

I was speaking a bit with BereanPatriot about this the other day, in fact, as he is working on a new Bible translation. Since all translation involves choice, I just couldn't be moved to take something like that on. Being blotted out of the Book of Life? Scary stuff. Count me out. Same goes for making rules where there aren't any (as I believe Mr. Tidwell, despite his presumably good intentions, might be guilty of).
 
Do I think everything is black and white? In principle, yes. Do I think we can rightly discern with perfect accuracy which is which, even with the help of the Spirit? Honestly, no. Paul had to withstand Peter to his face. Does anyone doubt they both were filled with the Holy Spirit? I sure don't. So I think good, godly, Spirit filled men can and do disagree on stuff. 🤷‍♂️
Just to clarify, Paul confronted Peter because Peter acted out of fear of the Jews; i.e. peer pressure. According to Galatians 2:12, he withdrew and separated himself, fearing those who were of the circumcision. This was no difference of understanding between these men, but a failure of Peter to stand for the truth (sound familiar!), so Paul got into his face over it.

I see no difference here with those preachers who acknowledge polygyny as not being wrong but who then side with the monogamy-only advocates. Paul called such actions hypocrisy (v:13), and it is. Peter's actions caused other men such as Barnabas to be carried away with their hypocrisy. Good people are led into error by the example of men acting as hypocrites, and it's nothing new to to the Church. The hypocrisy should be just as strongly challenged today as it was by Paul back then. Maybe we wouldn't see so many men now being thrown under the bus for having more than one wife if that were the case. 🤔
 
🤣 I did not say that your deductions were not good, bad or indifferent or that I even Disagree. I simply disagree that you can blantly just say that she was 13 as if it is established fact when it simply wasnt.

I can say she was probably around that age but I cant declare that she was definitely.

Umm maybe you have some strong feelings and thoughts too that drive you to present as fact something we will never actually know.
I actually read research online that suggested she was closer to 16. I believe being married at 13 was permissible but according to the research I read it was more common to be married around 16 at the time. I wouldn't claim that's solid or scripturally verifiable even, I just thought it was interesting.
 
Back
Top